A recent European conference related to performance planning and
reporting in the public sector has noted two important contributions
made by PMN and S. Montague in a paper titled 'Three Spheres of
Performance Governance: Spanning The Boundaries From
Single-Organizational Focus Towards A Partnership Network'. The two
important insights were noted in a paper by Petri Uusikylä and Ville
Valovirta prepared for the European Group of Public Administration (EGPA)
2004 Annual Conference – Four Months After: Administering The New
Europe, September 1-4, 2004, Ljubljana, Slovenia.
Uusikylä and Valovirta conclude:
“One of the important insights made by the Canadian public
management developers…The reach describes… According to Montague
(1998) the logic models which do not make a reference to who and
where the action is taking place, suffer from three key problems.
First, they lack the sensitivity to the impacts on different
participant groups. There is also a great potential to confuse
outputs and outcomes – the problem which we noticed already as
regards the logical framework approach. Third, the account of the
trade-off between the reach and the results remains often
underdeveloped. Too ambitious results are often expected since the
customer reach has not been identified.”
“Another great insight made by the Canadians is the division of the
performance objectives and measures into three spheres of influence
(Montague 2000). The first one is the operational sphere over which
the managers have a direct control. The second sphere is one of
behavioural change over which the managers have a direct control.
Here the question is how our actions modify people’s actions. The
third sphere the environment of indirect influence, affected by the
change of behaviour. What the model does is that it impersonates the
rather mechanistic approaches of performance management by employing
the concept of reach and by acknowledging the different degrees of
influence in the three spheres.”
For the entire presentation see
http://soc.kuleuven.be/pol/io/egpa/qual/ljubljana/Valovirta%20Uusikila_paper.pdf.